Difference between revisions of "Team:KU Leuven/Future/Economic potential analysis"

Line 61: Line 61:
  
 
     <!---------------------------------------------------Begin content-------------------------------------------->
 
     <!---------------------------------------------------Begin content-------------------------------------------->
−
<div class="summarytext1">
+
    <div class="summarytext1">
 
         <div class="part">
 
         <div class="part">
 
             <h2>
 
             <h2>
−
                 An economic rationale analysis for investing in the use of micro-organisms for the production of artificial bone                                     implants.
+
                 An economic rationale analysis for investing in the use of micro-organisms for
 +
                the production of artificial bone implants.
 
             </h2>
 
             </h2>
  
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
            Because our research contributes to the base of fundamental knowledge, it could be used as preliminary research for many applications. A brief look into the future potential, from an economic perspective, could possibly offer the rationale for a deeper research into the applications. As we will see, there are many opportunities and challenges that pop up and need to be addressed, even in this early stage. The main goal of this potential analysis is to construct a bridge between the pure scientific research and the commercial environment, resulting in a marketable product. In this analysis, we mainly focus on the use of Spot E.Shape principles for producing novel ways of producing artificial bone replacements. Although a similar analysis can be made for each of the other applications of the project. For more details on this, please go to the application section.  
+
                Because our research contributes to the base of fundamental knowledge, it could
 +
                be used as preliminary research for many applications. A brief look into the
 +
                future potential, from an economic perspective, could possibly offer the
 +
                rationale for a deeper research into the applications. As we will see, there are
 +
                many opportunities and challenges that pop up and need to be addressed, even in
 +
                this early stage. The main goal of this potential analysis is to construct a
 +
                bridge between the pure scientific research and the commercial environment,
 +
                resulting in a marketable product. In this analysis, we mainly focus on the use
 +
                of Spot E.Shape principles for producing novel ways of producing artificial bone
 +
                replacements. Although a similar analysis can be made for each of the other
 +
                applications of the project. For more details on this, please go to the
 +
                application section.
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
−
           
+
 
 
         </div>
 
         </div>
  
 
         <div class="part">
 
         <div class="part">
 
             <h2>
 
             <h2>
−
              A deeper understanding of the market and industry dynamics in the bone-implant industry
+
                A deeper understanding of the market and industry dynamics in the bone-implant
 +
                industry
 
             </h2>
 
             </h2>
  
 +
            <div class="center">
 +
                <div class="quote">
 +
                    <p>
 +
                        Nowadays, elderly people are more active than ever before. They cycle, play
 +
                        tennis, go swimming, travel, etc. Besides, they do not want to give up on those
 +
                        activities because of their age. Nevertheless, the risk of accidents with
 +
                        possibly serious health consequences and broken limbs grows with age.
 +
                        Approximately 1% of all falls of elderly people result in a hip fracture with an
 +
                        acute mortality of 3%-5%. (23)
 +
                    </p>
 +
                </div>
 +
            </div>
  
−
    <div class="center">
+
             <br></br>
−
        <div class="quote">
+
−
                <p>
+
−
            Nowadays, elderly people are more active than ever before. They cycle, play tennis, go swimming, travel, etc. Besides, they do not want to give up on those activities because of their age.  Nevertheless, the risk of accidents with possibly serious health consequences and broken limbs grows with age. Approximately 1% of all falls of elderly people result in a hip fracture with an acute mortality of 3%-5%. (23)
+
−
                </p>
+
−
        </div>
+
−
    </div>
+
−
 
+
−
             <br> </br>
+
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
The ageing population and active life-style trends are two major driving forces for the demand of orthopaedic devices. Apart from that, the medical world is confronted with an increasing number of obesity and osteoporosis patients. These factors result in an enhanced growth of the orthopaedic industry. Medical device companies respond by continuously looking for new ways of treating fractured bones in order to reduce the curing time and to obtain a more performant device.  
+
                The ageing population and active life-style trends are two major driving forces
 +
                for the demand of orthopaedic devices. Apart from that, the medical world is
 +
                confronted with an increasing number of obesity and osteoporosis patients. These
 +
                factors result in an enhanced growth of the orthopaedic industry. Medical device
 +
                companies respond by continuously looking for new ways of treating fractured
 +
                bones in order to reduce the curing time and to obtain a more performant device.
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
−
             <br> </br>
+
             <br></br>
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
A closer look into the industry dynamics reveals that the industry is highly regulated and very dynamic where most of the industry players are well-established small and medium-size enterprises (SME’s). A start-up company often needs a significant better product to gain some market share in the medical device industry. Many of them choose to first enter a niche market to establish some early market share. Once they obtained a solid position in the industry, they can broaden their horizon by reaching out to new, unexplored markets.  
+
                A closer look into the industry dynamics reveals that the industry is highly
 +
                regulated and very dynamic where most of the industry players are
 +
                well-established small and medium-size enterprises (SME’s). A start-up company
 +
                often needs a significant better product to gain some market share in the
 +
                medical device industry. Many of them choose to first enter a niche market to
 +
                establish some early market share. Once they obtained a solid position in the
 +
                industry, they can broaden their horizon by reaching out to new, unexplored
 +
                markets.
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
  
−
    </div>  
+
        </div>
  
−
    <div class="part">
+
        <div class="part">
 
             <h2>
 
             <h2>
−
              Relevance of using traditional materials for bone implants  
+
                Relevance of using traditional materials for bone implants
−
              </h2>
+
            </h2>
−
         
+
 
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Traditionally orthopaedic devices have titanium alloys as the dominant material used in most artificial bone implants. However alternatives with new and better functions having lower failure rates are finding their way to the industry. One of the most promising applications is tissue engineering where the cells from a patient or a donor are isolated. Thereafter, they are combined with biomaterials, grown in laboratories and then implanted into the patient. This futuristic approach is in fact becoming a reality and is facing some major concerns and drawbacks. The limited viable window from the point of extraction of cells to the reintroduction makes this technology less flexible. (4) The transportation of these cells to and from the laboratory is also a huge challenge. Besides, the storage of tissue engineered products (TEP) at a constant temperature of -37°C puts pressure on the cost-efficiency. (4) On top of that, tissue engineered products didn’t make a breakthrough in Europe due to the lack of regulation. TEP’s are beyond the medical device regulation and the pharmaceutical regulation. (4) This ambiguity concerning the regulation in Europe leads to a strong delay in market introduction. At the moment there is no dominant supply model based on mass production due to the capacity limits. This prevents TEP’s from really breaking through and becoming the industrially standard technology. (4)
+
                Traditionally orthopaedic devices have titanium alloys as the dominant material
 +
                used in most artificial bone implants. However alternatives with new and better
 +
                functions having lower failure rates are finding their way to the industry. One
 +
                of the most promising applications is tissue engineering where the cells from a
 +
                patient or a donor are isolated. Thereafter, they are combined with
 +
                biomaterials, grown in laboratories and then implanted into the patient. This
 +
                futuristic approach is in fact becoming a reality and is facing some major
 +
                concerns and drawbacks. The limited viable window from the point of extraction
 +
                of cells to the reintroduction makes this technology less flexible. (4) The
 +
                transportation of these cells to and from the laboratory is also a huge
 +
                challenge. Besides, the storage of tissue engineered products (TEP) at a
 +
                constant temperature of -37°C puts pressure on the cost-efficiency. (4) On top
 +
                of that, tissue engineered products didn’t make a breakthrough in Europe due to
 +
                the lack of regulation. TEP’s are beyond the medical device regulation and the
 +
                pharmaceutical regulation. (4) This ambiguity concerning the regulation in
 +
                Europe leads to a strong delay in market introduction. At the moment there is no
 +
                dominant supply model based on mass production due to the capacity limits. This
 +
                prevents TEP’s from really breaking through and becoming the industrially
 +
                standard technology. (4)
 +
 
 +
            </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
−
            </p><br> </br>
 
−
           
 
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
In the last decade, composite materials, polymers and ceramics steadily found their way to the medical device industry. This is mainly due to the lower failures rates, recalls and their lower weight. With our Spot E.Shape project, we would like to take this to the next level by imitating the natural bone structure as much as possible through the use of micro-organisms.  
+
                In the last decade, composite materials, polymers and ceramics steadily found
 +
                their way to the medical device industry. This is mainly due to the lower
 +
                failures rates, recalls and their lower weight. With our Spot E.Shape project,
 +
                we would like to take this to the next level by imitating the natural bone
 +
                structure as much as possible through the use of micro-organisms.
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
−
    </div>  
+
        </div>
  
−
    <div class="part">
+
        <div class="part">
 
             <h2>
 
             <h2>
−
              The positive consequences of using micro-organisms for bone engineering
+
                The positive consequences of using micro-organisms for bone engineering
 
             </h2>
 
             </h2>
−
         
+
 
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Spot E.Shape can be used for a wide range of bone prosthesis. Here we focus on hip prosthesis. Hip fractures impose an increased risk for complications which could seriously shorten the life expectancy.
+
                Spot E.Shape can be used for a wide range of bone prosthesis. Here we focus on
−
             </p><br> </br>
+
                hip prosthesis. Hip fractures impose an increased risk for complications which
−
           
+
                could seriously shorten the life expectancy.
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
 +
 
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
            Recently, surgeons are using a 3D printed implant made of titanium, polymers or ceramics for hip transplantations. Here the patient’s CT scan is used to design an exact replica of the femoral head. Our project could optimise this design by using bacteria that form and precipitate calcium carbonates in a controlled way. From there a porous, spongy structure similar to a bone can be formed. Thereafter, this can be used as a surface coating for the titanium alloy.  
+
                Recently, surgeons are using a 3D printed implant made of titanium, polymers or
−
</p><br> </br>
+
                ceramics for hip transplantations. Here the patient’s CT scan is used to design
 +
                an exact replica of the femoral head. Our project could optimise this design by
 +
                using bacteria that form and precipitate calcium carbonates in a controlled way.
 +
                From there a porous, spongy structure similar to a bone can be formed.
 +
                Thereafter, this can be used as a surface coating for the titanium alloy.
 +
            </p>
 +
            <br></br>
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
In order to identify and deal with the competitive implications of the so called salient attributes, we used the ACE Matrix (Attribute Categorization and Evaluation) by Ian C. MacMillan and Rita Gunther McGrath (21) applied to our orthopaedic device. The columns refer to the level of energy the attribute generates for the customer while the rows refer to the sentiment it provokes. (21) This analytic tool serves to identify the right mix and dynamic fit between the customer needs and the attributes of the product. (21) Particularly interesting are the powerful energizers that often become the determining factor for the purchase decision. The layer of calcium deposited by the bacteria can be seen as a coating for the titanium structure which reduces substantially the amount of constraint and wear of the prosthesis. Wear is something that more traditional metallic and polyethylene prosthesis have to deal with. Therefor it can have a great impact on the health.        
+
                In order to identify and deal with the competitive implications of the so called
−
</p><br> </br>
+
                salient attributes, we used the ACE Matrix (Attribute Categorization and
 +
                Evaluation) by Ian C. MacMillan and Rita Gunther McGrath (21) applied to our
 +
                orthopaedic device. The columns refer to the level of energy the attribute
 +
                generates for the customer while the rows refer to the sentiment it provokes.
 +
                (21) This analytic tool serves to identify the right mix and dynamic fit between
 +
                the customer needs and the attributes of the product. (21) Particularly
 +
                interesting are the powerful energizers that often become the determining factor
 +
                for the purchase decision. The layer of calcium deposited by the bacteria can be
 +
                seen as a coating for the titanium structure which reduces substantially the
 +
                amount of constraint and wear of the prosthesis. Wear is something that more
 +
                traditional metallic and polyethylene prosthesis have to deal with. Therefor it
 +
                can have a great impact on the health.
 +
            </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
−
<p> matrix
+
            <p>
 +
                matrix
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
  
−
<p>
+
            <p>
−
An important issue is that dissatisfiers can encourage the customers (mostly the surgeons) to opt for a competitor that reduces customer loyalty. (21) In the case of our medical device, it is crucial to conduct long-term experiments to test possible health effects. Additionally already in the prototyping phase, we need to start thinking about possible ways to automate and fasten the production process. An improved cost-effectiveness of the product could turn the tolerable into a differentiator. On the other hand, a competitor’s action can turn a tolerable into a dissatisfier, e.g. the competitor eliminates a negative characteristic. To be one step ahead of competition, we first need to look for ways to keep the price of our product under control.
+
                An important issue is that dissatisfiers can encourage the customers (mostly the
−
             </p><br> </br>
+
                surgeons) to opt for a competitor that reduces customer loyalty. (21) In the
 +
                case of our medical device, it is crucial to conduct long-term experiments to
 +
                test possible health effects. Additionally already in the prototyping phase, we
 +
                need to start thinking about possible ways to automate and fasten the production
 +
                process. An improved cost-effectiveness of the product could turn the tolerable
 +
                into a differentiator. On the other hand, a competitor’s action can turn a
 +
                tolerable into a dissatisfier, e.g. the competitor eliminates a negative
 +
                characteristic. To be one step ahead of competition, we first need to look for
 +
                ways to keep the price of our product under control.
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
−
<p>
+
            <p>
−
We have to remark that the validation phase concerning the customer perceptions of attributes still needs to be performed. Keep also in mind that this analysis is a foresight for a medical device application, which implies that at this stage, not every attribute can be proved scientifically.
+
                We have to remark that the validation phase concerning the customer perceptions
 +
                of attributes still needs to be performed. Keep also in mind that this analysis
 +
                is a foresight for a medical device application, which implies that at this
 +
                stage, not every attribute can be proved scientifically.
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
−
    </div>  
+
        </div>
−
 
+
 
−
    <div class="part">
+
        <div class="part">
 
             <h2>
 
             <h2>
−
              Barriers for the market introduction of orthopaedic materials based on micro-organisms  
+
                Barriers for the market introduction of orthopaedic materials based on
 +
                micro-organisms
 
             </h2>
 
             </h2>
−
         
+
 
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Introducing a brand new technology often comes with some major challenges to overcome. In this section, we are focusing on the different potential issues that need to be addressed in further stages of the project. We identify three of them, namely the financial gap, regulation gap and human capital gap.  
+
                Introducing a brand new technology often comes with some major challenges to
−
             </p><br> </br>
+
                overcome. In this section, we are focusing on the different potential issues
 +
                that need to be addressed in further stages of the project. We identify three of
 +
                them, namely the financial gap, regulation gap and human capital gap.
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
−
              <h4>
+
            <h4>
−
              Financial gap
+
                Financial gap
−
              </h4>
+
            </h4>
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Orthopaedic research is often time-consuming and requires a substantial investment during the development, production and distribution phase before it can be translated into a final product for patient care. (7) At the current proof-of-concept phase of the project, we already experience a clear need for financials. Radical innovations typically need large investments in further technological development before a first working prototype can be constructed and tested. (14) From the perspective of potential investors, there is a lot of uncertainty about the outcome which will probably lead to a long payback time and thus few economic incentives to invest in this early stage of the project. (13) The phenomenon of investor reluctance is often described as ‘the financial barrier’ which plays a role on the level of private financiers, such as banks and venture capital firms. (16) The need for government stimulants through specialised funding programs is clearly present. (12) This is underlined by the fact that publicly funded venture capital firms are more willing to consider investing in early-stage university spin-outs than private ones (15).  
+
                Orthopaedic research is often time-consuming and requires a substantial
−
             </p><br> </br>
+
                investment during the development, production and distribution phase before it
 +
                can be translated into a final product for patient care. (7) At the current
 +
                proof-of-concept phase of the project, we already experience a clear need for
 +
                financials. Radical innovations typically need large investments in further
 +
                technological development before a first working prototype can be constructed
 +
                and tested. (14) From the perspective of potential investors, there is a lot of
 +
                uncertainty about the outcome which will probably lead to a long payback time
 +
                and thus few economic incentives to invest in this early stage of the project.
 +
                (13) The phenomenon of investor reluctance is often described as ‘the financial
 +
                barrier’ which plays a role on the level of private financiers, such as banks
 +
                and venture capital firms. (16) The need for government stimulants through
 +
                specialised funding programs is clearly present. (12) This is underlined by the
 +
                fact that publicly funded venture capital firms are more willing to consider
 +
                investing in early-stage university spin-outs than private ones (15).
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Beside the proof-of-concept phase, the pre-seed funding phase further explores managerial and organisational aspects of the project in order to make it more attractive for potential investors. (12) In the proof-of-concept phase, government funding mainly serves the role of reducing the technological uncertainty while the reduction of the organisational uncertainty is mainly the purpose of pre-seed funding. For this phase we are currently fully relying on sponsorship from the industry and university organisations. For further research, the option of applying for a governmental grant remains possible.  
+
                Beside the proof-of-concept phase, the pre-seed funding phase further explores
−
             </p><br> </br>    
+
                managerial and organisational aspects of the project in order to make it more
 +
                attractive for potential investors. (12) In the proof-of-concept phase,
 +
                government funding mainly serves the role of reducing the technological
 +
                uncertainty while the reduction of the organisational uncertainty is mainly the
 +
                purpose of pre-seed funding. For this phase we are currently fully relying on
 +
                sponsorship from the industry and university organisations. For further
 +
                research, the option of applying for a governmental grant remains possible.
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
−
          <p>
+
            <p>
−
The third major phase or seed phase takes place when the company is established, but basically it does not generate enough cash flow to survive on its own. For their early investments, investors are often given an equity stake in return. Attracting venture capital investors remains difficult because they prefer to invest in university spin-outs after the seed phase, when the research and following application proved to be robust. (17) Possible investors should be found in the industry, angel investors, crowd funding, government, etc.  
+
                The third major phase or seed phase takes place when the company is established,
−
             </p><br> </br>
+
                but basically it does not generate enough cash flow to survive on its own. For
 +
                their early investments, investors are often given an equity stake in return.
 +
                Attracting venture capital investors remains difficult because they prefer to
 +
                invest in university spin-outs after the seed phase, when the research and
 +
                following application proved to be robust. (17) Possible investors should be
 +
                found in the industry, angel investors, crowd funding, government, etc.
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
−
          <p>
+
            <p>
−
When a company grows, at some point in time there will be an immediate financial need that is too high to bear for traditional investors. Often regional and national venture capital firms are then the only option to turn at. (11) However venture capital firms should be a well-considered decision. They bring along a new working culture, make demands (e.g. hiring professional managers and administrators) and put pressure on the firm to get the necessary in-house competences. All of this is done with respect to the return-on-investment they need so desperately regarding their 10-year horizon. (11) Venture capital firms could lead to tremendous progress for the company or they can break up with the company in the long term because growing organically with the company is not their primary strategic concern. (11)  
+
                When a company grows, at some point in time there will be an immediate financial
 +
                need that is too high to bear for traditional investors. Often regional and
 +
                national venture capital firms are then the only option to turn at. (11) However
 +
                venture capital firms should be a well-considered decision. They bring along a
 +
                new working culture, make demands (e.g. hiring professional managers and
 +
                administrators) and put pressure on the firm to get the necessary in-house
 +
                competences. All of this is done with respect to the return-on-investment they
 +
                need so desperately regarding their 10-year horizon. (11) Venture capital firms
 +
                could lead to tremendous progress for the company or they can break up with the
 +
                company in the long term because growing organically with the company is not
 +
                their primary strategic concern. (11)
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
  
−
              <h4>
+
            <h4>
−
              Regulation gap
+
                Regulation gap
−
              </h4>
+
            </h4>
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
A lack of regulation can be considered as double-edged, where it shortens the product innovation cycle but at the same time makes marketing your product more complicated. (s) Orthopaedic devices are normally classified as a medical device and fall within the European medical device regulation. To be issued with a CE mark, medical devices must achieve high quality, safety and performance standards. (18) However the specificity of our device, which is based on the precipitation by bacteria, could possibly be subject to the regulation of genetically modified organisms. The narrow legal framework concerning GMO’s in Europe could affect and delay the innovation process of our orthopaedic device. The ambiguity and lack of clarity to which regulation our application can be applied, shows the need for the realignment of regulation with practice and current state-of-technology. (19)
+
                A lack of regulation can be considered as double-edged, where it shortens the
−
             </p><br> </br>
+
                product innovation cycle but at the same time makes marketing your product more
 +
                complicated. (s) Orthopaedic devices are normally classified as a medical device
 +
                and fall within the European medical device regulation. To be issued with a CE
 +
                mark, medical devices must achieve high quality, safety and performance
 +
                standards. (18) However the specificity of our device, which is based on the
 +
                precipitation by bacteria, could possibly be subject to the regulation of
 +
                genetically modified organisms. The narrow legal framework concerning GMO’s in
 +
                Europe could affect and delay the innovation process of our orthopaedic device.
 +
                The ambiguity and lack of clarity to which regulation our application can be
 +
                applied, shows the need for the realignment of regulation with practice and
 +
                current state-of-technology. (19)
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
−
              <h4>
+
            <h4>
−
              Human capital gap  
+
                Human capital gap
−
              </h4>
+
            </h4>
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Knockaert et al. suggested that “One of the principal challenges facing university spin-outs is academic entrepreneurs tending to possess little commercial human capital.” (15) The fact that they are experts in their domain does not make them the perfect marketers for their product. As showed above, the orthopaedic industry is characterised by a certain set of aspects. Appropriate managers will more likely find more adapted ways of dealing with these differences. Besides there are possible conflicts of interest with the traditional roles of research and teaching that might pop up when academic entrepreneurs need to run a business. (20) Raising venture capital should also be done by an entrepreneur who possesses lots of commercial human capital. This shows clearly that the different challenges are interrelated. (15)  
+
                Knockaert et al. suggested that “One of the principal challenges facing
−
             </p>  
+
                university spin-outs is academic entrepreneurs tending to possess little
 +
                commercial human capital.” (15) The fact that they are experts in their domain
 +
                does not make them the perfect marketers for their product. As showed above, the
 +
                orthopaedic industry is characterised by a certain set of aspects. Appropriate
 +
                managers will more likely find more adapted ways of dealing with these
 +
                differences. Besides there are possible conflicts of interest with the
 +
                traditional roles of research and teaching that might pop up when academic
 +
                entrepreneurs need to run a business. (20) Raising venture capital should also
 +
                be done by an entrepreneur who possesses lots of commercial human capital. This
 +
                shows clearly that the different challenges are interrelated. (15)
 +
             </p>
  
−
</div>  
+
        </div>
−
 
+
 
−
  <div class="part">
+
        <div class="part">
 
             <h2>
 
             <h2>
−
              Desired approach for the market introduction
+
                Desired approach for the market introduction
 
             </h2>
 
             </h2>
−
         
+
 
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
The orthopaedic device industry is currently confronted with a rising demand for new orthopaedic prosthesis devices. To deal with this, we came up with a brand new device based on the use of bacteria. However we described three major barriers that can potentially disturb the realisation of its economic potential. The purpose of this section is not to provide an exhaustive description of a go-to-market-strategy or business plan, but rather briefly offering some guidelines that need to be kept in mind to secure a bright future perspective.  
+
                The orthopaedic device industry is currently confronted with a rising demand for
−
             </p><br></br>
+
                new orthopaedic prosthesis devices. To deal with this, we came up with a brand
 +
                new device based on the use of bacteria. However we described three major
 +
                barriers that can potentially disturb the realisation of its economic potential.
 +
                The purpose of this section is not to provide an exhaustive description of a
 +
                go-to-market-strategy or business plan, but rather briefly offering some
 +
                guidelines that need to be kept in mind to secure a bright future perspective.
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Parallel to tissue engineered products, where they also work with cells (4), the end product is highly customized and falls under the ‘Make to Order’ approach. In view of the high demand of orthopaedic products, this will not be sufficient to establish a competitive supply model that is capable of gathering a significant part of the market. The way to deal with this obstacle should be to identify all the parts that can be automated and scaled-up already in an early stage of the development process in order to satisfy a possibly mass market. (4) In order to commercialize the device, there should also be thought off patenting the invention. The Bayh–Dole-inspired legislation made this possible for universities and was adopted by many countries in their national regulation. (12)
+
                Parallel to tissue engineered products, where they also work with cells (4), the
−
             </p><br></br>
+
                end product is highly customized and falls under the ‘Make to Order’ approach.
 +
                In view of the high demand of orthopaedic products, this will not be sufficient
 +
                to establish a competitive supply model that is capable of gathering a
 +
                significant part of the market. The way to deal with this obstacle should be to
 +
                identify all the parts that can be automated and scaled-up already in an early
 +
                stage of the development process in order to satisfy a possibly mass market. (4)
 +
                In order to commercialize the device, there should also be thought off patenting
 +
                the invention. The Bayh–Dole-inspired legislation made this possible for
 +
                universities and was adopted by many countries in their national regulation.
 +
                (12)
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
There comes a time when you can not do everything on your own anymore, especially in an industry where multiple disciplines overlap and different competences are needed. (see figure 2) The interdisciplinary aspect is one way to explain the search for the right strategic partner to forge an alliance with. The reduction of technological uncertainty in the early phases of a project could be a second reason for collaboration with a partner from industry. (5) This will make the search for potential investors a lot easier and reduce the time-to-market for the application. This is also often the phase where a university spin-off is created, which acts like an independent business.  
+
                There comes a time when you can not do everything on your own anymore,
−
             </p><br></br>
+
                especially in an industry where multiple disciplines overlap and different
 +
                competences are needed. (see figure 2) The interdisciplinary aspect is one way
 +
                to explain the search for the right strategic partner to forge an alliance with.
 +
                The reduction of technological uncertainty in the early phases of a project
 +
                could be a second reason for collaboration with a partner from industry. (5)
 +
                This will make the search for potential investors a lot easier and reduce the
 +
                time-to-market for the application. This is also often the phase where a
 +
                university spin-off is created, which acts like an independent business.
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
Anecdotal evidence states that it is very hard to become profitable as a company from the start, but the goal of taking market share by aiming a niche market is a much more realistic objective than reaching a positive cash flow. Once this is obtained, the company will be considered as an interesting investment for the big medical device companies which will be eager to take over the company. However if the ultimate goal of market share is not reached, the company will not generate a breakthrough and succumb rapidly. (4)
+
                Anecdotal evidence states that it is very hard to become profitable as a company
−
             </p><br></br>
+
                from the start, but the goal of taking market share by aiming a niche market is
 +
                a much more realistic objective than reaching a positive cash flow. Once this is
 +
                obtained, the company will be considered as an interesting investment for the
 +
                big medical device companies which will be eager to take over the company.
 +
                However if the ultimate goal of market share is not reached, the company will
 +
                not generate a breakthrough and succumb rapidly. (4)
 +
             </p>
 +
            <br></br>
  
 
             <p>
 
             <p>
−
In conclusion, we can say that a spin-off is most likely to be chosen in combination with the necessary patents and partners.  
+
                In conclusion, we can say that a spin-off is most likely to be chosen in
 +
                combination with the necessary patents and partners.
 
             </p>
 
             </p>
−
    </div>  
+
        </div>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
  
 +
    <div class="summaryheader">
 +
        <div class="summaryimg">
 +
            <img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b7/KU_Leuven_Researchbanner.jpg"
 +
                width="100%">
 +
            <div class="head">
 +
                <h2>References</h2>
  
−
<div class="summaryheader">
+
            </div>
−
<div class="summaryimg">
+
        </div>
−
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b7/KU_Leuven_Researchbanner.jpg"
+
    </div>
−
width="100%">
+
−
<div class="head">
+
−
<h2>References</h2>
+
  
−
</div>
+
    <!--------------------------------------------------Foot don't touch!------------------------------------------------------>
−
</div>
+
    <div class="subsections">
 +
        <div class="subsectionwrapper">
 +
            <div class="subimgrow">
 +
                <div class="subimg">
 +
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/More applications">
 +
                        <img
 +
                            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e9/KU_Leuven_Wiki_Button_-_Other_applications2.png"
 +
                            width="100%">
 +
                    </a>
 +
                </div>
  
 +
                <div class="whitespace"></div>
  
−
<!--------------------------------------------------Foot don't touch!------------------------------------------------------>
+
                <div class="subimg">
−
<div class="subsections">
+
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/Future collaboration">
−
<div class="subsectionwrapper">
+
                        <img
−
<div class="subimgrow">
+
                            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e0/KU_Leuven_Wiki_Button_-_Collaboration2.png"
−
<div class="subimg">
+
                            width="100%">
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/More applications">
+
                    </a>
−
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e9/KU_Leuven_Wiki_Button_-_Other_applications2.png" width="100%">
+
                </div>
−
</a>
+
−
</div>
+
  
−
<div class="whitespace">
+
                <div class="whitespace"></div>
−
</div>
+
  
−
<div class="subimg">
+
                <div class="subimg">
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/Future collaboration">
+
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future">
−
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e0/KU_Leuven_Wiki_Button_-_Collaboration2.png" width="100%">
+
                        <img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/c/cb/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Back.png"
−
</a>
+
                            width="100%">
−
</div>
+
                    </a>
 +
                </div>
 +
            </div>
  
−
<div class="whitespace">
+
            <div class="subtextrow">
−
</div>
+
                <div class="subtext">
 +
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/More applications">
 +
                        <h2>More applications</h2>
 +
                        <p>Click here to discover our other applications.
 +
                            <br/>
 +
                        </p>
 +
                    </a>
 +
                </div>
  
−
<div class="subimg">
+
                <div class="whitespace"></div>
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future">
+
−
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/c/cb/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Back.png" width="100%" >
+
−
</a>
+
−
</div>
+
−
</div>
+
  
−
<div class="subtextrow">
+
                <div class="subtext">
−
<div class="subtext">
+
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/Future collaboration">
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/More applications">
+
                        <h2>Future collaboration</h2>
−
<h2>More applications</h2>
+
                        <p>
−
<p>Click here to discover our other applications.
+
                            A brief description how a future collaboration with the TU Delft iGEM team could
−
<br/>
+
                            be formed.
−
</p>
+
                            <br/>
−
</a>
+
                        </p>
−
</div>
+
                    </a>
 +
                </div>
  
−
<div class="whitespace">
+
                <div class="whitespace"></div>
−
</div>
+
  
−
<div class="subtext">
+
                <div class="subtext">
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/Future collaboration">
+
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future">
−
<h2>Future collaboration</h2>
+
                        <h2>Back</h2>
−
<p> A brief description how a future collaboration with the TU Delft iGEM team could be formed.
+
                        <p>Go back to the Future page.
−
<br/>
+
                            <br/>
−
</p>
+
                        </p>
−
</a>
+
                    </a>
−
</div>
+
                </div>
 +
            </div>
  
−
<div class="whitespace">
+
            <div class="subimgreadmore">
−
</div>
+
                <div class="subimgrm">
 +
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/More applications">
 +
                        <div id="more">
 +
                            <img alt="Read more" height="40%"
 +
                                src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/73/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Read_more.png"
 +
                                width="85%">
 +
                        </div>
 +
                    </a>
 +
                </div>
  
−
<div class="subtext">
+
                <div class="whitespace"></div>
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future">
+
−
<h2>Back</h2>
+
−
<p>Go back to the Future page.
+
−
<br/>
+
−
</p>
+
−
</a>
+
−
</div>
+
−
</div>
+
  
−
<div class="subimgreadmore">
+
                <div class="subimgrm">
−
<div class="subimgrm">
+
                    <a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/Future collaboration">
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/More applications">
+
                        <div id="more">
−
<div id="more">
+
                            <img alt="Read more" height="40%"
−
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/73/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Read_more.png" height="40%" width="85%" alt="Read more">
+
                                src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/73/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Read_more.png"
−
</div>
+
                                width="85%">
−
</a>
+
                        </div>
−
</div>
+
                    </a>
 +
                </div>
  
−
<div class="whitespace">
+
                <div class="whitespace"></div>
−
</div>
+
  
−
<div class="subimgrm">
+
                <div class="subimgrm">
−
<a href="https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future/Future collaboration">
+
                    <a href=" https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future">
−
<div id="more">
+
                        <div id="back">
−
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/73/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Read_more.png" height="40%" width="85%" alt="Read more">
+
                            <img alt="Read more" height="40%"
−
</div>
+
                                src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/73/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Read_more.png"
−
</a>
+
                                width="85%">
−
</div>
+
                        </div>
 +
                    </a>
 +
                </div>
 +
            </div>
  
−
<div class="whitespace">
+
        </div>
−
</div>
+
  
−
<div class="subimgrm">
+
    </div>
−
<a href=" https://2015.igem.org/Team:KU_Leuven/Future">
+
−
<div id="back">
+
−
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/73/KUL_Wiki_Button_-_Read_more.png" height="40%" width="85%" alt="Read more">
+
 
</div>
 
</div>
−
</a>
 
 
</div>
 
</div>
−
</div>
 
−
 
−
 
−
 
−
</div>
 
−
 
−
 
−
</div>
 
−
</div>
 
−
</div>
 
−
 
  
 
<div id="summarywrapper">
 
<div id="summarywrapper">
 
<div class="summary">
 
<div class="summary">
−
<h3>
+
    <h3>
−
Contact
+
        Contact
−
</h3>
+
    </h3>
−
<p style="font-size:1.3em; text-align: center">
+
    <p style="font-size:1.3em; text-align: center">
−
Address: Celestijnenlaan 200G room 00.08 - 3001 Heverlee<br>
+
        Address: Celestijnenlaan 200G room 00.08 - 3001 Heverlee<br>
−
Telephone: +32(0)16 32 73 19<br>
+
        Telephone: +32(0)16 32 73 19<br>
−
Email: igem@chem.kuleuven.be<br>
+
        Email: igem@chem.kuleuven.be<br>
−
</p>
+
    </p>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 347: Line 539:
 
<div id="footer">
 
<div id="footer">
 
<div class="rowfooter">
 
<div class="rowfooter">
−
<div class="emptyfooter"></div>
+
    <div class="emptyfooter"></div>
−
<div id="bioscenter">
+
    <div id="bioscenter">
−
<a href="http://www.kuleuven.be/bioscenter/"><img alt="bioSCENTer"
+
        <a href="http://www.kuleuven.be/bioscenter/"><img alt="bioSCENTer"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/3/3c/KU_Leuven_Logo_BioSCENTer.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/3/3c/KU_Leuven_Logo_BioSCENTer.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div class="emptyfooter"></div>
+
    <div class="emptyfooter"></div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
 
<div class="rowfooter">
 
<div class="rowfooter">
−
<div id="lrd">
+
    <div id="lrd">
−
<a href="http://lrd.kuleuven.be/"><img alt="KU Leuven Research & Development"
+
        <a href="http://lrd.kuleuven.be/"><img alt="KU Leuven Research & Development"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b4/KU_Leuven_HR_LRD_CMYK_LOGO.jpg"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b4/KU_Leuven_HR_LRD_CMYK_LOGO.jpg"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="youreca">
+
    <div id="youreca">
−
<a href="http://www.kuleuven.be/onderzoek/youreca/"><img alt="YOURECA"
+
        <a href="http://www.kuleuven.be/onderzoek/youreca/"><img alt="YOURECA"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/4/4f/KU_Leuven_YOURECA.png" width="95%"></a>
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/4/4f/KU_Leuven_YOURECA.png" width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="solvay">
+
    <div id="solvay">
−
<a href="http://www.solvay.com/"><img alt="SOLVAY"
+
        <a href="http://www.solvay.com/"><img alt="SOLVAY"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/8/89/KU_Leuven_Solvay_Transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/8/89/KU_Leuven_Solvay_Transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="medicine">
+
    <div id="medicine">
−
<a href="http://gbiomed.kuleuven.be/english"><img alt="Faculty of Medicine"
+
        <a href="http://gbiomed.kuleuven.be/english"><img alt="Faculty of Medicine"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/8/83/KU_Leuven_Biomedische_Wetenschappen_logo_.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/8/83/KU_Leuven_Biomedische_Wetenschappen_logo_.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
 
<div class="rowfooter">
 
<div class="rowfooter">
−
<div id="imec">
+
    <div id="imec">
−
<a href="http://www2.imec.be/be_en/home.html"><img alt="imec"
+
        <a href="http://www2.imec.be/be_en/home.html"><img alt="imec"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/70/KU_Leuven_Imec_logo_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/7/70/KU_Leuven_Imec_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="genzyme">
+
    <div id="genzyme">
−
<a href="http://www.genzyme.be/"><img alt="Genzyme"
+
        <a href="http://www.genzyme.be/"><img alt="Genzyme"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b7/KU_Leuven_Genzyme_logo_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b7/KU_Leuven_Genzyme_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="eppendorf">
+
    <div id="eppendorf">
−
<a href="https://www.eppendorf.com/BE-en/"><img alt="Eppendorf"
+
        <a href="https://www.eppendorf.com/BE-en/"><img alt="Eppendorf"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/9/96/KU_Leuven_Logo_Eppendorf_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/9/96/KU_Leuven_Logo_Eppendorf_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="kuleuven">
+
    <div id="kuleuven">
−
<a href="http://www.kuleuven.be/english"><img alt="bioSCENTer"
+
        <a href="http://www.kuleuven.be/english"><img alt="bioSCENTer"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/0/08/KULEUVEN_groot.png" width="95%"></a>
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/0/08/KULEUVEN_groot.png" width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div class="spacefooter"></div>
+
    <div class="spacefooter"></div>
−
<div id="gips">
+
    <div id="gips">
−
<a href="http://www.gipsmineral.de/"><img alt="Gips Mineral"
+
        <a href="http://www.gipsmineral.de/"><img alt="Gips Mineral"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/3/3d/KU_Leuven_Gips_Mineral_logo_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/3/3d/KU_Leuven_Gips_Mineral_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="kolo">
+
    <div id="kolo">
−
<a><img alt="Ko-Lo Instruments"
+
        <a><img alt="Ko-Lo Instruments"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/1/15/KUL_Ko-Lo_Instruments_logo_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/1/15/KUL_Ko-Lo_Instruments_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="regensys">
+
    <div id="regensys">
−
<a href="http://regenesys.eu/"><img alt="Regenesys"
+
        <a href="http://regenesys.eu/"><img alt="Regenesys"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/eb/KU_Leuven_Logo_Regenesys_Transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/eb/KU_Leuven_Logo_Regenesys_Transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
 
<div class="rowfooter">
 
<div class="rowfooter">
−
<div id="bioke">
+
    <div id="bioke">
−
<a href="https://www.bioke.com/"><img alt="Bioké"
+
        <a href="https://www.bioke.com/"><img alt="Bioké"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e1/KUL_Biok%C3%A9_logo_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e1/KUL_Biok%C3%A9_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="thermofisher">
+
    <div id="thermofisher">
−
<a href="https://www.fishersci.com/us/en/home.html"><img alt="Thermo Fisher Scientific"
+
        <a href="https://www.fishersci.com/us/en/home.html"><img alt="Thermo Fisher Scientific"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/a/aa/KUL_Fischer_Scientific_logo_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/a/aa/KUL_Fischer_Scientific_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="vwr">
+
    <div id="vwr">
−
<a
+
        <a
−
href="https://be.vwr.com/store/?&_requestid=866148&_DARGS=/store/cms/be.vwr.com/nl_BE/header_20159241139103.jsp.1_AF&_dynSessConf=4047468000326453053&targetURL=/store/%3F%26_requestid%3D866148&lastLanguage=en&/vwr/userprofiling/EditPersonalInfoFormHandler.updateLocale=&_D%3AcurrentLanguage=+&currentLanguage=en&_D%3AlastLanguage=+&_D%3A/vwr/userprofiling/EditPersonalInfoFormHandler.updateLocale=+"><img alt="VWR"
+
            href="https://be.vwr.com/store/?&_requestid=866148&_DARGS=/store/cms/be.vwr.com/nl_BE/header_20159241139103.jsp.1_AF&_dynSessConf=4047468000326453053&targetURL=/store/%3F%26_requestid%3D866148&lastLanguage=en&/vwr/userprofiling/EditPersonalInfoFormHandler.updateLocale=&_D%3AcurrentLanguage=+&currentLanguage=en&_D%3AlastLanguage=+&_D%3A/vwr/userprofiling/EditPersonalInfoFormHandler.updateLocale=+"><img alt="VWR"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/8/8d/KU_Leuven_Logo_VWR_transparant_.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/8/8d/KU_Leuven_Logo_VWR_transparant_.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="footerimg">
+
    <div id="footerimg">
−
<img
+
        <img
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b9/KU_Leuven_Zebra_spots_wiki_footer_main.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/b/b9/KU_Leuven_Zebra_spots_wiki_footer_main.png"
−
width="95%">
+
            width="95%">
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="gimv">
+
    <div id="gimv">
−
<a href="http://www.gimv.com/en"><img alt="Gimv"
+
        <a href="http://www.gimv.com/en"><img alt="Gimv"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/a/ac/KU_Leuven_Logo_Gimv_Transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/a/ac/KU_Leuven_Logo_Gimv_Transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div id="machery">
+
    <div id="machery">
−
<a href="http://www.filterservice.be/"><img alt="Machery Nagel"
+
        <a href="http://www.filterservice.be/"><img alt="Machery Nagel"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/4/41/KU_Leuven_Macherey_Nagel_logo_transparant.png"
+
            src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/4/41/KU_Leuven_Macherey_Nagel_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
            width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
−
<div class="logosmall">
+
    <div class="logosmall">
−
<div id="sigma">
+
        <div id="sigma">
−
<a href="https://www.sigmaaldrich.com/belgium-nederlands.html"><img alt="Sigma-Aldrich"
+
            <a href="https://www.sigmaaldrich.com/belgium-nederlands.html"><img alt="Sigma-Aldrich"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/4/4b/KUL_Sigma-Aldrich_logo_transparant.png"
+
                src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/4/4b/KUL_Sigma-Aldrich_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
                width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
        </div>
−
<div id="egilabo">
+
        <div id="egilabo">
−
<a href="http://www.egilabo.be/"><img alt="Egilabo"
+
            <a href="http://www.egilabo.be/"><img alt="Egilabo"
−
src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e9/KUL_Egilabo_logo_transparant.png"
+
                src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2015/e/e9/KUL_Egilabo_logo_transparant.png"
−
width="95%"></a>
+
                width="95%"></a>
−
</div>
+
        </div>
−
</div>
+
    </div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 470: Line 662:
 
   */
 
   */
 
function scroll_if_anchor(href) {
 
function scroll_if_anchor(href) {
−
     href = typeof(href) == "string" ? href : $(this).attr("href");
+
     href = typeof(href) == "string"
 +
        ? href
 +
        : $(this).attr("href");
  
 
     // If href missing, ignore
 
     // If href missing, ignore
−
     if(!href) return;
+
     if (!href)  
−
 
+
        return;
 +
   
 
     // You could easily calculate this dynamically if you prefer
 
     // You could easily calculate this dynamically if you prefer
 
     var fromTop = 500;
 
     var fromTop = 500;
Line 484: Line 679:
 
     // Older browsers without pushState might flicker here, as they momentarily
 
     // Older browsers without pushState might flicker here, as they momentarily
 
     // jump to the wrong position (IE < 10)
 
     // jump to the wrong position (IE < 10)
−
     if($target.length) {
+
     if ($target.length) {
−
         $('html, body').animate({ scrollTop: $target.offset().top - fromTop });
+
         $('html, body').animate({
−
         if(history && "pushState" in history) {
+
            scrollTop: $target.offset().top - fromTop
 +
        });
 +
         if (history && "pushState" in history) {
 
             history.pushState({}, document.title, window.location.pathname + href);
 
             history.pushState({}, document.title, window.location.pathname + href);
 
             return false;
 
             return false;
 
         }
 
         }
 
     }
 
     }
−
}  
+
}
  
 
// When our page loads, check to see if it contains and anchor
 
// When our page loads, check to see if it contains and anchor

Revision as of 13:59, 17 September 2015

Logo

Economic potential analysis

An economic rationale analysis for investing in the use of micro-organisms for the production of artificial bone implants.

Because our research contributes to the base of fundamental knowledge, it could be used as preliminary research for many applications. A brief look into the future potential, from an economic perspective, could possibly offer the rationale for a deeper research into the applications. As we will see, there are many opportunities and challenges that pop up and need to be addressed, even in this early stage. The main goal of this potential analysis is to construct a bridge between the pure scientific research and the commercial environment, resulting in a marketable product. In this analysis, we mainly focus on the use of Spot E.Shape principles for producing novel ways of producing artificial bone replacements. Although a similar analysis can be made for each of the other applications of the project. For more details on this, please go to the application section.

A deeper understanding of the market and industry dynamics in the bone-implant industry

Nowadays, elderly people are more active than ever before. They cycle, play tennis, go swimming, travel, etc. Besides, they do not want to give up on those activities because of their age. Nevertheless, the risk of accidents with possibly serious health consequences and broken limbs grows with age. Approximately 1% of all falls of elderly people result in a hip fracture with an acute mortality of 3%-5%. (23)



The ageing population and active life-style trends are two major driving forces for the demand of orthopaedic devices. Apart from that, the medical world is confronted with an increasing number of obesity and osteoporosis patients. These factors result in an enhanced growth of the orthopaedic industry. Medical device companies respond by continuously looking for new ways of treating fractured bones in order to reduce the curing time and to obtain a more performant device.



A closer look into the industry dynamics reveals that the industry is highly regulated and very dynamic where most of the industry players are well-established small and medium-size enterprises (SME’s). A start-up company often needs a significant better product to gain some market share in the medical device industry. Many of them choose to first enter a niche market to establish some early market share. Once they obtained a solid position in the industry, they can broaden their horizon by reaching out to new, unexplored markets.

Relevance of using traditional materials for bone implants

Traditionally orthopaedic devices have titanium alloys as the dominant material used in most artificial bone implants. However alternatives with new and better functions having lower failure rates are finding their way to the industry. One of the most promising applications is tissue engineering where the cells from a patient or a donor are isolated. Thereafter, they are combined with biomaterials, grown in laboratories and then implanted into the patient. This futuristic approach is in fact becoming a reality and is facing some major concerns and drawbacks. The limited viable window from the point of extraction of cells to the reintroduction makes this technology less flexible. (4) The transportation of these cells to and from the laboratory is also a huge challenge. Besides, the storage of tissue engineered products (TEP) at a constant temperature of -37°C puts pressure on the cost-efficiency. (4) On top of that, tissue engineered products didn’t make a breakthrough in Europe due to the lack of regulation. TEP’s are beyond the medical device regulation and the pharmaceutical regulation. (4) This ambiguity concerning the regulation in Europe leads to a strong delay in market introduction. At the moment there is no dominant supply model based on mass production due to the capacity limits. This prevents TEP’s from really breaking through and becoming the industrially standard technology. (4)



In the last decade, composite materials, polymers and ceramics steadily found their way to the medical device industry. This is mainly due to the lower failures rates, recalls and their lower weight. With our Spot E.Shape project, we would like to take this to the next level by imitating the natural bone structure as much as possible through the use of micro-organisms.

The positive consequences of using micro-organisms for bone engineering

Spot E.Shape can be used for a wide range of bone prosthesis. Here we focus on hip prosthesis. Hip fractures impose an increased risk for complications which could seriously shorten the life expectancy.



Recently, surgeons are using a 3D printed implant made of titanium, polymers or ceramics for hip transplantations. Here the patient’s CT scan is used to design an exact replica of the femoral head. Our project could optimise this design by using bacteria that form and precipitate calcium carbonates in a controlled way. From there a porous, spongy structure similar to a bone can be formed. Thereafter, this can be used as a surface coating for the titanium alloy.



In order to identify and deal with the competitive implications of the so called salient attributes, we used the ACE Matrix (Attribute Categorization and Evaluation) by Ian C. MacMillan and Rita Gunther McGrath (21) applied to our orthopaedic device. The columns refer to the level of energy the attribute generates for the customer while the rows refer to the sentiment it provokes. (21) This analytic tool serves to identify the right mix and dynamic fit between the customer needs and the attributes of the product. (21) Particularly interesting are the powerful energizers that often become the determining factor for the purchase decision. The layer of calcium deposited by the bacteria can be seen as a coating for the titanium structure which reduces substantially the amount of constraint and wear of the prosthesis. Wear is something that more traditional metallic and polyethylene prosthesis have to deal with. Therefor it can have a great impact on the health.



matrix

An important issue is that dissatisfiers can encourage the customers (mostly the surgeons) to opt for a competitor that reduces customer loyalty. (21) In the case of our medical device, it is crucial to conduct long-term experiments to test possible health effects. Additionally already in the prototyping phase, we need to start thinking about possible ways to automate and fasten the production process. An improved cost-effectiveness of the product could turn the tolerable into a differentiator. On the other hand, a competitor’s action can turn a tolerable into a dissatisfier, e.g. the competitor eliminates a negative characteristic. To be one step ahead of competition, we first need to look for ways to keep the price of our product under control.



We have to remark that the validation phase concerning the customer perceptions of attributes still needs to be performed. Keep also in mind that this analysis is a foresight for a medical device application, which implies that at this stage, not every attribute can be proved scientifically.

Barriers for the market introduction of orthopaedic materials based on micro-organisms

Introducing a brand new technology often comes with some major challenges to overcome. In this section, we are focusing on the different potential issues that need to be addressed in further stages of the project. We identify three of them, namely the financial gap, regulation gap and human capital gap.



Financial gap

Orthopaedic research is often time-consuming and requires a substantial investment during the development, production and distribution phase before it can be translated into a final product for patient care. (7) At the current proof-of-concept phase of the project, we already experience a clear need for financials. Radical innovations typically need large investments in further technological development before a first working prototype can be constructed and tested. (14) From the perspective of potential investors, there is a lot of uncertainty about the outcome which will probably lead to a long payback time and thus few economic incentives to invest in this early stage of the project. (13) The phenomenon of investor reluctance is often described as ‘the financial barrier’ which plays a role on the level of private financiers, such as banks and venture capital firms. (16) The need for government stimulants through specialised funding programs is clearly present. (12) This is underlined by the fact that publicly funded venture capital firms are more willing to consider investing in early-stage university spin-outs than private ones (15).



Beside the proof-of-concept phase, the pre-seed funding phase further explores managerial and organisational aspects of the project in order to make it more attractive for potential investors. (12) In the proof-of-concept phase, government funding mainly serves the role of reducing the technological uncertainty while the reduction of the organisational uncertainty is mainly the purpose of pre-seed funding. For this phase we are currently fully relying on sponsorship from the industry and university organisations. For further research, the option of applying for a governmental grant remains possible.



The third major phase or seed phase takes place when the company is established, but basically it does not generate enough cash flow to survive on its own. For their early investments, investors are often given an equity stake in return. Attracting venture capital investors remains difficult because they prefer to invest in university spin-outs after the seed phase, when the research and following application proved to be robust. (17) Possible investors should be found in the industry, angel investors, crowd funding, government, etc.



When a company grows, at some point in time there will be an immediate financial need that is too high to bear for traditional investors. Often regional and national venture capital firms are then the only option to turn at. (11) However venture capital firms should be a well-considered decision. They bring along a new working culture, make demands (e.g. hiring professional managers and administrators) and put pressure on the firm to get the necessary in-house competences. All of this is done with respect to the return-on-investment they need so desperately regarding their 10-year horizon. (11) Venture capital firms could lead to tremendous progress for the company or they can break up with the company in the long term because growing organically with the company is not their primary strategic concern. (11)

Regulation gap

A lack of regulation can be considered as double-edged, where it shortens the product innovation cycle but at the same time makes marketing your product more complicated. (s) Orthopaedic devices are normally classified as a medical device and fall within the European medical device regulation. To be issued with a CE mark, medical devices must achieve high quality, safety and performance standards. (18) However the specificity of our device, which is based on the precipitation by bacteria, could possibly be subject to the regulation of genetically modified organisms. The narrow legal framework concerning GMO’s in Europe could affect and delay the innovation process of our orthopaedic device. The ambiguity and lack of clarity to which regulation our application can be applied, shows the need for the realignment of regulation with practice and current state-of-technology. (19)



Human capital gap

Knockaert et al. suggested that “One of the principal challenges facing university spin-outs is academic entrepreneurs tending to possess little commercial human capital.” (15) The fact that they are experts in their domain does not make them the perfect marketers for their product. As showed above, the orthopaedic industry is characterised by a certain set of aspects. Appropriate managers will more likely find more adapted ways of dealing with these differences. Besides there are possible conflicts of interest with the traditional roles of research and teaching that might pop up when academic entrepreneurs need to run a business. (20) Raising venture capital should also be done by an entrepreneur who possesses lots of commercial human capital. This shows clearly that the different challenges are interrelated. (15)

Desired approach for the market introduction

The orthopaedic device industry is currently confronted with a rising demand for new orthopaedic prosthesis devices. To deal with this, we came up with a brand new device based on the use of bacteria. However we described three major barriers that can potentially disturb the realisation of its economic potential. The purpose of this section is not to provide an exhaustive description of a go-to-market-strategy or business plan, but rather briefly offering some guidelines that need to be kept in mind to secure a bright future perspective.



Parallel to tissue engineered products, where they also work with cells (4), the end product is highly customized and falls under the ‘Make to Order’ approach. In view of the high demand of orthopaedic products, this will not be sufficient to establish a competitive supply model that is capable of gathering a significant part of the market. The way to deal with this obstacle should be to identify all the parts that can be automated and scaled-up already in an early stage of the development process in order to satisfy a possibly mass market. (4) In order to commercialize the device, there should also be thought off patenting the invention. The Bayh–Dole-inspired legislation made this possible for universities and was adopted by many countries in their national regulation. (12)



There comes a time when you can not do everything on your own anymore, especially in an industry where multiple disciplines overlap and different competences are needed. (see figure 2) The interdisciplinary aspect is one way to explain the search for the right strategic partner to forge an alliance with. The reduction of technological uncertainty in the early phases of a project could be a second reason for collaboration with a partner from industry. (5) This will make the search for potential investors a lot easier and reduce the time-to-market for the application. This is also often the phase where a university spin-off is created, which acts like an independent business.



Anecdotal evidence states that it is very hard to become profitable as a company from the start, but the goal of taking market share by aiming a niche market is a much more realistic objective than reaching a positive cash flow. Once this is obtained, the company will be considered as an interesting investment for the big medical device companies which will be eager to take over the company. However if the ultimate goal of market share is not reached, the company will not generate a breakthrough and succumb rapidly. (4)



In conclusion, we can say that a spin-off is most likely to be chosen in combination with the necessary patents and partners.

References

More applications

Click here to discover our other applications.

Future collaboration

A brief description how a future collaboration with the TU Delft iGEM team could be formed.

Back

Go back to the Future page.

Read more
Read more
Read more

Contact

Address: Celestijnenlaan 200G room 00.08 - 3001 Heverlee
Telephone: +32(0)16 32 73 19
Email: igem@chem.kuleuven.be