Difference between revisions of "Team:Cambridge-JIC/Practices"

 
(207 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{:Team:Cambridge-JIC/Templates/Menu}}
 
{{:Team:Cambridge-JIC/Templates/Menu}}
 
<html>
 
<html>
<section style="background-color: #fff">
+
 
     <div class="slide">
+
<section style="background-color: #fff; padding-top:30px">
        <div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
     <div class="slide" style="min-height:200px">
            <h1>Human Practices: The Open Hardware Revolution</h1>
+
<center>
            <p style="font-size: 120%">In choosing the novel Hardware Track, this years’ Cambridge-JIC iGEM team has come across unexpected challenges. Unsurprisingly perhaps, these have often required us to look into fields of work that we have had little or no previous experience in. This has been particularly true when navigating the world of intellectual property law, including <span class="hl_2">hardware licensing</span> and <span class="hl_2">design copyright</span>. In developing Open Source Hardware (OSH) as part of the competition, we recognised the need for an easily-digestible, comprehensive and hardware-specific guide to ensuring the OSH is accessible to the community.
+
<img src="//2015.igem.org/wiki/images/e/e8/CamJIC-Home_Community.png" style="height:150px;">
</p>
+
</center>
            <h4>Open source hardware is hardware whose design is made publicly available so that anyone can study, modify, distribute, make, and sell the design or hardware based on that design.</h4>
+
    </div>
<h4>OSH is “free as in free speech, not free beer” or more formally <i>Libre</i> rather than <i>Gratis</i>.</h4>
+
</section>
 +
 
 +
<section style="background-color: #c6b2e4">
 +
    <div class="slide" style="background-image:url(//2015.igem.org/wiki/images/2/22/CamJIC-Community_Outreach.png);position:relative">
 +
        <div style="right:37%;top:50%;font-size:20px;position:absolute">
 +
        <a class="btn btn-default btn-lg" href="//2015.igem.org/Team:Cambridge-JIC/Outreach" role="button" style="color:#3d3d3d;border-color:#3d3d3d">Learn More</a>
 +
        </div>
 +
<div style="left:15%;right:50%;top:25%;font-size:20px;position:absolute">
 +
      <p><b>Our survey </b> on the public perception of Synthetic Biology suggested communicating research was a challenge</p>
 +
      <p>By organising workshops for school students, we increased awareness of its potential benefits <b>for future generations</b></p>
 +
        </div>
 +
<div style="left:52%;right:10%;top:25%;font-size:20px;position:absolute">
 +
      <p>We introduced students to programming and modern microscopy techniques, <b> taking them beyond the school syllabus</b><p>
 
         </div>
 
         </div>
 
     </div>
 
     </div>
 
</section>
 
</section>
  
         <style>
+
<section style="background-color: #f3f3f3">
            #cam-quiz {
+
    <div class="slide" style="background-image:url(//2015.igem.org/wiki/images/4/47/CamJIC-Community_Practices.png);position:relative">
                background-color: #fff;
+
         <div style="right:15%;top:67%;font-size:20px;position:absolute">
                border: 0px;
+
        <a class="btn btn-default btn-lg" href="//2015.igem.org/Team:Cambridge-JIC/OpenHardwareRevolution" role="button" style="color:#123a68;border-color:#123a68">Learn More</a>
            }
+
        </div>
 +
<div style="left:60%;right:5%;top:9%;font-size:20px;position:absolute;color:#123a68">
 +
      <p>Developing hardware brings with it issues of <b>licensing, patent and copyright</b></p>
 +
      <p><b>From our experience,</b> navigating the legal jargon and complex procedures can be prohibitively time-consuming</p>
 +
        </div>
 +
<div style="left:40%;right:30%;top:60%;font-size:20px;position:absolute;color:#123a68">
 +
      <p><b>For iGEM teams</b><br>looking to release Open Source Hardware, we have made an interactive guide to use as a starting point</p>
 +
    </div>
 +
</section>
  
            .cam-quiz-question, .cam-quiz-result {
+
<section style="background-color: #b1e7ad">
                border: 5px solid;
+
    <div class="slide" style="background-image:url(//2015.igem.org/wiki/images/a/aa/CamJIC-About_Collaboration.png);position:relative">
                border-color: #a3c1ad;
+
        <div style="right:76%;top:74%;font-size:20px;position:absolute">
                padding: 5px;
+
        <a class="btn btn-default btn-lg" href="//2015.igem.org/Team:Cambridge-JIC/Collaborations" role="button" style="color:#3d3d3d;border-color:#3d3d3d">Learn More</a>
                margin: 0px;
+
        </div>
            }
+
<div style="left:5%;right:40%;top:30%;font-size:20px;position:absolute;color:#1b4f18">
 +
      <p><b>The William and Mary iGEM team</b> are using GFP in the Interlab Measurement study</p>
 +
      <p><b>The Glasgow iGEM team</b> are using GFP and RFP to make bioluminescent bacteria</p>
 +
        </div>
 +
<div style="left:13%;right:20%;top:57%;font-size:20px;position:absolute;color:#1b4f18">
 +
      <p>Collaboration meant confirming the expression of their fluorescent proteins while <b>testing OpenScope's capabilities</b></p>
 +
        </div>
 +
    </div>
 +
</section>
  
            .cam-quiz-question {
+
<section style="background-color:#fff">
                background-color: #fff;
+
    <div class="slide" style="background-image:url(//2015.igem.org/wiki/images/d/d6/CamJIC-Project_Wiki.png); position:relative">
            }
+
         <div style="right:44%;bottom:65%;font-size:20px;position:absolute">
 
+
<a class="btn btn-default btn-lg" href="//2015.igem.org/Team:Cambridge-JIC/Wiki_Design" role="button" style="color:#123a68;border-color:#123a68">Learn More</a>
            .cam-quiz-answer.cam-quiz-selected {
+
        </div>
                font-weight: bold;
+
<div style="left:36%;right:29%;top:75%;font-size:20px;position:absolute;color:#123a68">
            }
+
        <p><b>A map of our entire wiki</b>, in case you can't find what you're looking for</p>
 
+
        <p><b>Some advice</b> for future iGEM teams on making a wiki</p>
            .cam-quiz-result {
+
        </div>
                background-color: #fff;
+
    </div>
            }
+
</section>
        </style>
+
        <script>
+
            quiz = function(elem){
+
                this.elem = $(elem);
+
                this.steps = [];
+
 
+
                this.step = function(question, answers) {
+
                    this.question = question;
+
                    this.answers = {};
+
                    this.bind = function(target, keys) {
+
                        if (typeof keys === "undefined") {
+
                            keys = Object.keys(this.answers);
+
                        }
+
 
+
                        for (var i=0; i<keys.length; i++) {
+
                            key = keys[i];
+
                            this.answers[key].target = target;
+
                        }
+
                    };
+
                    this.elem = function(quiz, index) {
+
                        elem = $('<div class="cam-quiz-question">');
+
                        elem.append($('<h3>').text(this.question));
+
                        for (key in this.answers) {
+
                            elem.append($('<div class="cam-quiz-answer">')
+
                                .text(this.answers[key].answer)
+
                                .data("key", key)
+
                                .data("step", this)
+
                                .data("quiz", quiz)
+
                                .data("index", index)
+
                                .click(function(){
+
                                    key = $(this).data("key");
+
                                    step = $(this).data("step");
+
                                    quiz = $(this).data("quiz");
+
                                    index = $(this).data("index");
+
                                    ref = quiz.steps[index];
+
                                    ref.elem.find('.cam-quiz-selected').removeClass('cam-quiz-selected');
+
                                    $(this).addClass('cam-quiz-selected');
+
 
+
                                    for (var i=quiz.steps.length; --i>index;) {
+
                                        quiz.steps[i].elem.remove();
+
                                        quiz.steps.pop();
+
                                    }
+
 
+
                                    quiz.steps[index].option = key;
+
                                    nstep = step.answers[key].target;
+
                                    switch (typeof nstep) {
+
                                        case "object":
+
                                            var nindex = quiz.steps.length;
+
                                            var nref = {
+
                                                'step': nstep,
+
                                                'elem': nstep.elem(quiz, nindex),
+
                                                'option': undefined
+
                                            };
+
                                            quiz.steps.push(nref);
+
                                            quiz.elem.append(nref.elem);
+
                                            break;
+
                                        case "function":
+
                                            options = [];
+
                                            for (var i=0; i<quiz.steps.length; i++) {
+
                                                options.push(quiz.steps[i].option);
+
                                            }
+
                                            var nref = {
+
                                                'step': undefined,
+
                                                'elem': $('<div class="cam-quiz-result">')
+
                                                    .append(nstep(options)),
+
                                                'option': undefined
+
                                            };
+
                                            quiz.steps.push(nref);
+
                                            quiz.elem.append(nref.elem);
+
                                            break;
+
                                        default:
+
                                            alert("Quiz error! Please contact the site maintainers....");
+
                                            break;
+
                                    }
+
                                }));
+
                        }
+
                        return elem;
+
                    };
+
 
+
                    for (key in answers) {
+
                        answer = answers[key];
+
                        this.answers[key] = {
+
                            'answer': answer,
+
                            'target': undefined
+
                        };
+
                    }
+
                };
+
 
+
                this.start = function(step) {
+
                    index = this.steps.length;
+
                    ref = {
+
                        'step': step,
+
                        'elem': step.elem(this, index),
+
                        'option': undefined
+
                    };
+
                    this.steps.push(ref);
+
                    this.elem.append(ref.elem);
+
                };
+
            };
+
 
+
            $(document).ready(function(){
+
                q = new quiz('#cam-quiz');
+
 
+
                step0 = new q.step("You have developed a new product, complete with design files, source code and documentation.", {
+
                    1: "Proceed"
+
                });
+
                step1 = new q.step("Do you want to release your product for others to remix and customize?", {
+
                    0: "no",
+
                    1: "yes"
+
                });
+
                step2a = new q.step("Do you want complete legal control over your product at all times and to prevent derivatisation?", {
+
                    0: "no",
+
                    1: "yes"
+
                });
+
                step2b = new q.step("Do you want to have the option to legally impose conditions such as attribution?", {
+
                    0: "no",
+
                    1: "yes"
+
                });
+
                step3a = new q.step("Do you want to commercialise your product and make it proprietary?", {
+
                    0: "no",
+
                    1: "yes"
+
                });
+
                step3b = new q.step("Do you want to allow for proprietary derivatives being made from your designs?", {
+
                    0: "no",
+
                    1: "yes"
+
                });
+
                step3c = new q.step("Your product could be released under the CCO 'No Rights Reserved' License, or even unlicensed.", {
+
                    1: "Learn more"
+
                });
+
                step4a = new q.step("Your product could be released under standard commercial license.", {
+
                    1: "OK"
+
                });
+
                step4b = new q.step("Your product could be released under a CC NonCommercial - NoDerivs license.", {
+
                    1: "OK"
+
                });
+
                step4c = new q.step("A Permissive license is most appropriate for your product.", {
+
                    1: "OK"
+
                });
+
                step4d = new q.step("A Copyleft license is most appropriate for your product. This can be general or hardware-specific.", {
+
                    0: "General",
+
                    1: "Hardware-specific"
+
                });
+
                step5a = new q.step("Examples of Permissive licenses include: BSD, MIT and CC Attribution.", {
+
                    1: "Learn more"
+
                });
+
                step5b = new q.step("Learn more about the hardware-specific Copyleft options:", {
+
                    0: "CERN OHL (more widely used)",
+
                    1: "TAPR OHL"
+
                });
+
                step5c = new q.step("Learn more about the general Copyleft options:", {
+
                    0: "GNU GPL (software license)",
+
                    1: "Viral licenses,, eg. CC Attribution - ShareAlike licenses"
+
                });
+
                step5d = new q.step("Your product is no longer open-source hardware (OSH), and should not be labelled as such.", {
+
                    1: "Learn more about OSH"
+
                });
+
 
+
final3c = function(options) {
+
      window.location.href="#CC0";
+
      return $('<h3>').text('You are being redirected to the page with information about the CC0 license.')
+
}
+
 
+
final5a = function(options) {
+
      window.location.href="#permissive";
+
      return $('<h3>').text('You are being redirected to the page with information about Permissive licenses.')
+
}
+
 
+
final5b0 = function(options) {
+
      window.location.href="#CERN";
+
      return $('<h3>').text('You are being redirected to the page with information about the CERN OHL.')
+
}
+
 
+
final5b1 = function(options) {
+
      window.location.href="#TAPR";
+
      return $('<h3>').text('You are being redirected to the page with information about the TAPR OHL.')
+
}
+
 
+
final5c0 = function(options) {
+
      window.location.href="#GNU";
+
      return $('<h3>').text('You are being redirected to the page with information about the GNU GPL.')
+
}
+
 
+
final5c1 = function(options) {
+
      window.location.href="#viral";
+
      return $('<h3>').text('You are being redirected to the page with information about viral licenses.')
+
}
+
 
+
final5d = function(options) {
+
      window.location.href="#OSH";
+
      return $('<h3>').text('You are being redirected to the page with information about OSH.')
+
}
+
 
+
                step0.bind(step1, [1]);
+
                step1.bind(step2a, [0]);
+
                step1.bind(step2b, [1]);
+
                step2a.bind(step2b, [0]);
+
                step2a.bind(step3a, [1]);
+
                step2b.bind(step3c, [0]);
+
                step2b.bind(step3b, [1]);
+
                step3a.bind(step4b, [0]);
+
                step3a.bind(step4a, [1]);
+
                step3b.bind(step4d, [0]);
+
                step3b.bind(step4c, [1]);
+
                step3c.bind(final3c, [1]);
+
                step4a.bind(step5d, [1]);
+
                step4b.bind(step5d, [1]);               
+
                step4c.bind(step5a, [1]);
+
                step4d.bind(step5c, [0]);
+
                step4d.bind(step5b, [1]);
+
                step5a.bind(final5a, [1]);
+
                step5b.bind(final5b0, [0]);
+
                step5b.bind(final5b1, [1]);
+
                step5c.bind(final5c0, [0]);
+
                step5c.bind(final5c1, [1]);
+
                step5d.bind(final5d, [1]);
+
+
                q.start(step0);
+
            });
+
 
+
         </script>
+
 
+
    <section>
+
<div class="slide">
+
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
        <div id="cam-quiz" style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px">
+
<h2> Find the License for your Project </h2>
+
</div></div>
+
    </section>
+
 
+
 
+
<section style="background-color:#ababab" id="CC0">
+
<div class="slide">
+
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
<h2> CC0 and Unlicensed Work </h2>
+
<p>The Creative Commons ‘No Rights Reserved license’ (known as the CC0 license) essentially waives all copyrights you have over you work. This means there is no legal protection against you works being used, modified, redistributed or made proprietary.</p>
+
<p>Under the CC0 anyone can access your work, and use it in any way they want. However, you cannot license the work of other people under the CC0 unless you have express permission to do so or they have also used the CC0 license. This is an example of license compatibility issues (see compatibility tables).</p>
+
<p>Unlicensed work released into the public domain can be used by anyone in any way, again meaning that continued access cannot be ensured. Creative Commons recommends using the  ‘Public Domain Mark’ for this work. This is intended for old works that are already in the public domain without copyright in order to provide information about them [18].</p>
+
</div></div></section>
+
 
+
<section style="background-color:#12a34b" id="permissive">
+
<div class="slide">
+
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
<h2> Permissive Licenses </h2>
+
<p>Features of Permissive licenses:</p>
+
<ul>
+
<li><p>There are no reciprocity requirements when using a Permissive license. Redistributors can restrict access to derivative products and make them proprietary [17]</p></li>
+
<li><p>Hence they make it more likely that a given product will be repackaged and commercialised [15]</p></li>
+
<li><p>This is seen by some as a driving force for innovation and an additional freedom compared to Copyleft licenses [13]</p></li>
+
<li><p>They are designed to be legally simple and compatible with a greater variety of downstream licenses than Copyleft licenses (see compatibility charts)</p></li>
+
<li><p>It is important to recognise that any improvements on the product that are made proprietary will not be available to the community. This is not a problem with Copyleft licenses.</p></li>
+
</ul>
+
<p>A variety of Permissive licenses are available (Fig. 5, Fig. 6), and recently it has been proposed to develop a new one based on the Apache 2.0 software license as this is already well established [14].</p>
+
</div></div></section>
+
 
+
<section style="background-color:#ababab" id="CERN">
+
<div class="slide">
+
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
<h2> CERN OHL </h2>
+
<p>The CERN OHL was developed to do for hardware what the General Public License (GPL) did for software, and is available for free download (1). In 2009, scientists in the community at CERN began to create the Open Hardware Repository: “a place on the web for electronics designers at experimental physics facilities to collaborate on open hardware designs, much in the philosophy of the free software movement” [10].</p>
+
<p>The fundamental principals of the CERN OHL are:
+
<ul>
+
<li><p>If modifications are to be released to the community, they must be under the same license scheme as the original product</p></li>
+
<li><p>This ensures that the license is persistent, and ultimately everyone in the community benefits</p></li>
+
<li><p>The process of improvement uses collaboration between anyone in the community</p></li>
+
</ul>
+
<p>CERN itself uses the license to release Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs) that it develops back into the physics community. CERN recognised the potentially huge benefit of releasing hardware to the community, where it is effectively peer-reviewed and reconfigured to precisely match end-user requirements [10].</p>
+
<p>Notable new projects that have taken up the CERN OHL include Adafruit Industries and Citoyens Capteurs, which aims to develop a network of citizen air pollution sensors (amongst other OSH programs) [11].</p>
+
</div></div></section>
+
 
+
<section style="background-color:#12a34b" id="TAPR">
+
<div class="slide">
+
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
<h2> TAPR OHL </h2>
+
<p>The TAPR OHL was developed by Tucson Amateur Packet Radio, and like the CERN OHL was created to extend the success of OSS licenses (2). It is available for anyone to use, and can be downloaded directly from their website(3)  [12]. Just like the CERN OHL it is a Copyleft or ‘viral’ license: the terms applied to one product are propagated to all downstream products. In short, this means that once a product is made open-source, it and all it’s modifications remain accessible to the community.</p>
+
<p>The key premises of the TAPR OHL are outlined below, as described by the official website [12]:</p>
+
<ol type="i">
+
<li><p>Products can be used for any legal purpose</p></li>
+
<li><p>Unmodified documentation can be released, but it must be in the form of the entire package</p></li>
+
<li><p>Products can be commercially released as long as the documentation is also freely released, or is available for free for up to 3 years</p></li>
+
<li><p>All modifications must be released under the OHL</p></li>
+
<li><p>All modifications must be well documented, and attempts made to notify the designers of the original product</p></li>
+
</ol>
+
<p>Overall, the above requirements ensure that nobody is denied the rights to access the product and its documentation, including all downstream versions.</p>
+
<p>For more information on TAPR licensing procedures, see here</p>
+
</div></div></section>
+
 
+
 
+
<section style="background-color:#ababab" id="GNU">
+
<div class="slide">
+
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
<h2> GNU GPL </h2>
+
<p>The GNU General Public License (GPL) is the paradigm for Copyleft licenses. It was developed by Richard Stallman of the Free Software Foundation in the context of Free Open Source Software (FOSS). Here, as with OSH, the reference to ‘free’ is in terms of freedom and not cost.</p>
+
<p>The license agrees with, and established the four essential freedoms of FOSS:</p>
+
<p>Freedom 0 – the freedom to use the work<br>Freedom 1 – the freedom to study the work<br>Freedom 2 – the freedom to copy and share the work with others<br>Freedom 3 – the freedom to modify the work, and the freedom to distribute modified and therefore derivative works</p>
+
<p>As a software-specific license, the GNU GPL does not fall within the scope of our project. However, it is worth mentioning that many of the current OSH licenses were developed on the standards of the GPL and in an attempt to achieve what the GPL has in the context of hardware.</p>
+
<p>For more information about the GNU GPL, visit http://www.gnu.org/.</p>
+
</div></div></section>
+
 
+
<section style="background-color:#12a34b" id="viral">
+
<div class="slide">
+
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
+
<h2> Viral Licenses </h2>
+
</div></div></section>
+
  
<section style="background-color:#12a34b" id="OSH">
 
<div class="slide">
 
<div style="width: 80%; margin: 30px 50px;color:#000;min-height:0px">
 
<h2> Open Source Hardware </h2>
 
</div></div></section>
 
  
 
</html>
 
</html>
 
{{:Team:Cambridge-JIC/Templates/Footer}}
 
{{:Team:Cambridge-JIC/Templates/Footer}}

Latest revision as of 00:08, 19 September 2015

Our survey on the public perception of Synthetic Biology suggested communicating research was a challenge

By organising workshops for school students, we increased awareness of its potential benefits for future generations

We introduced students to programming and modern microscopy techniques, taking them beyond the school syllabus

Developing hardware brings with it issues of licensing, patent and copyright

From our experience, navigating the legal jargon and complex procedures can be prohibitively time-consuming

For iGEM teams
looking to release Open Source Hardware, we have made an interactive guide to use as a starting point

The William and Mary iGEM team are using GFP in the Interlab Measurement study

The Glasgow iGEM team are using GFP and RFP to make bioluminescent bacteria

Collaboration meant confirming the expression of their fluorescent proteins while testing OpenScope's capabilities

A map of our entire wiki, in case you can't find what you're looking for

Some advice for future iGEM teams on making a wiki